DAYCARE NIGHTMARE

Why Separating Mothers and Babies Harms Us All—and What We Must Do to Heal

Chapter One

All truth passes through three stages. First, it is ridiculed. Second, it is violently opposed. Third, it is accepted as self-evident.

—Often attributed to Arthur Schopenhauer

⁓

“Hello, this is Dr. Welden’s office calling for Diane Hansen.”

“This is Diane.”

“We have the results of your pregnancy test.”

With heart pounding … “Yes?”

“The test was positive. You are pregnant.”

“Oh my God,” I screamed, with tears streaming down my face.

The receptionist tried to tell me what would happen at my next appointment but it quickly became clear I would need some time to calm down.

“Please call us back when you are able to talk.”

“Of course. Thank you so much!”

A miracle was happening! A miracle my husband, Roy, and I had dreamed about for years and hoped would come true against some pretty heavy odds. You see, Roy had complications leading to low sperm count. We wondered if we could ever have a child together.

So when we decided to do all we could to make it happen we went to see an infertility specialist. He recommended we do a procedure called intrauterine insemination, which would make the most of what we had to work with. He explained it usually takes three to five tries, if it’s going to work at all. We got it on the first try!

⁓

For any couple longing to have a baby, news of a pregnancy is joyous. It’s one of those profound moments when life seems more meaningful and filled with possibility. Most parents want the best for their kids. They hope to see them grow up to be healthy, happy, and successful. If you ask them if they want a boy or a girl they will usually say they just want a healthy baby. But just as they are still receiving congratulations, most parents in our culture have to start thinking of who will raise their child for them while they are at work. And so begins a host of concerns about how best to prepare for handing over the little bundle. During those first critical months, as they are getting to know the newest member of their family, instead of settling in together and learning how to become the most connected, confident, and loving parents they can be, they are thinking of the best option in the neighborhood that fits their budget. As the time approaches to hand over the baby to return to work, the dreams of parenthood can seem to evaporate as the realities of modern life descend like a bad dream. Who can we trust to raise our baby the way we would? Is that even possible?

Mothers have always worked. What is relatively new, on a mass scale, is mothers of babies and very young children working away from home and being separated from them for much of the day.

When I was a kid in the ‘60s, most mothers were home. When I was in my twenties in the ‘80s, more moms were working. By the time I had my son in the ‘90s, the majority of mothers with young children were employed outside the home. The same forces, centered around the feminist movement, that led women to seek employment even when they had the resources to stay home, also shaped the information mothers would receive about whether daycare is a healthy option for their babies. The idea was to make it seem just fine, even beneficial, for children to spend their days away from mom so that she could pursue her career interests unimpeded. It was imperative mothers not be saddled with guilt and that they keep making the choice to leave their children for “meaningful” work out in the world.

So the story that developed, mostly with good intentions, was daycare was actually beneficial for all children, giving them a head start academically and socially. As we will see, this “creation of reality” often involved biased research plans and presentation of the results. Researchers who reported even slightly negative findings about the effects of time spent in daycare were branded as chauvinists who wanted to send women back into the Dark Ages and were shunned by the academic community.

Those in the media who promoted this newfound freedom for mothers to develop themselves outside of the home and “have it all” were happy to help frame daycare research findings in the most positive light possible, or to avoid reporting negative findings altogether. As the decades have gone by, this new reality—the new life script for women—has resulted in millions of mothers with children under three, the critical age for healthy brain development, working outside of the home and placing their babies and toddlers in some form of daycare. Most Americans have come to believe:

  • Mothers of young children have to work to make it in our economic system.
  • Daycare can’t be that bad for children, and may even provide benefits, such as earlier socialization and preparation for school.
  • Kids are resilient.
  • We all have to adjust to the demands of modern life.

The main story promoted by developmental psychologistsa and the mainstream media was—and still is—that with “quality” daycare, an oxymoron that does not truly exist, as we shall see, children and their parents, especially their mothers, will thrive. Further, taxpayer dollars should be used to provide this “opportunity” for every child from birth to age 5. But even a cursory look at the statistics on child and adolescent mental health reveals a starkly different reality:

We are not thriving.

Considering the sheer numbers of children struggling in one way or another, quite a different picture emerges.b

According to data from the 2021 and 2022 National parent survey of Children’s Health, 19 percent—nearly one in five—of America’s children ages two to eight have been diagnosed with at least one mental, behavioral, or developmental disorder. This represented an increase from 17.4 percent in 2016.1

Broadening our lens to include older children and adolescents, ages three to seventeen, the reality is deeply troubling:

  • An estimated 7 million children—11.7 percent—currently have an ADHD diagnosis.2
  • Approximately 6.6 million children—11 percent—have diagnosed anxiety.
  • Approximately 4.8 million children—8 percent—have a diagnosed behavioral disorder.
  • Approximately 2.4 million children—4 percent—have diagnosed depression.

Almost 2 million children 3–17 have diagnosed depression, with some of these conditions occurring together like anxiety and depression.3

Many of the children represented in these statistics suffer from more than one condition. Among children diagnosed with ADHD, for example, nearly 78 percent have at least one co-occurring condition, such as anxiety, depression, a learning disorder, or behavioral or conduct problems. Many with such diagnoses are treated with mind-altering, psychotropic medications. Further, most of those are prescribed off-label meaning they have not been approved by the FDA for children because it remains unclear whether those chemicals may be having negative, long-term effects on their rapidly developing brains. As disturbing as these numbers are, the most shocking and horrifying are those pertaining to infants, toddlers, and preschoolers—particularly children from birth to age three, the age group which is the primary focus of this book.

A large study of more than half a million Medicaid-enrolled children documented psychotropic prescriptions for thousands of very young children, including infants under one. These included medications used to treat ADHD, depression, anxiety, psychosis, and bipolar disorder.4 Despite the profound implications of exposing the rapidly developing brains of infants and toddlers to strong, mind-altering psychotropic drugs, the United States does not appear to maintain current, publicly available national data on how many children this young are receiving them. Further, there is not one federally funded human study that follows infants and toddlers being given psychotropic drugs that directly measures their subsequent brain development. One might be led to conclude they don’t want to know.

Perhaps the most dramatic examples of our failure to grow healthy, resilient children are child suicide and school shootings—which often involve suicide as well.

According to the CDC, the suicide rate among children ages ten to fourteen tripled between 2007 and 2018, rising from 0.9 to 2.9 deaths per 100,000, and remained unchanged through 2021. In 2023, almost 10 percent of American high school students reported attempting suicide during the previous twelve months.

When examining the American phenomenon of school shootings, there is disagreement about whether it can be called an epidemic, but what is clear is they occur frequently enough to affect every schoolchild’s experience. Nearly every public school in America now conducts lockdown drills as standard procedure, hoping to prepare students for the time when a fellow classmate may decide to open fire. Furthermore, connecting back to the tragedy of child suicide, Jonathan Singer, then board president of the American Association of Suicidology observed that “youth today are much more familiar with death,” citing more than twenty years of mass shootings at schools among the reasons. A special chapter in this book is devoted to the question of how someone could become a school shooter, using the life of Columbine killer Dylan Klebold as a case study. Information about his childhood and video footage of him speaking days before the massacre, viewed through the lens of attachment theory and neuroscience, provide the basis for a possible explanation.

Regarding the continuing deterioration in our children’s mental health, Gabor Maté, physician, trauma specialist, and best-selling author says:

If we’re seeing … all these problems arise on such a broad scale we really have to ask what is going on. And it’s not enough to blame individual kids for behaving badly or parents for not parenting properly, because if that was the problem we’d see individual cases here and there, but we wouldn’t see these problems manifest on such a widespread social level. And if we are seeing that then we have to ask what is going on in society …. If you were looking at a plant that was not developing properly in your garden you wouldn’t start blaming it for making the wrong choice.5

Not everyone believes it’s acceptable for mothers to separate from their babies. There are microcultures within the broader society, including some religious groups and immigrant families, that recognize the value—in fact, the necessity—of remaining close during those early years. Many other parents make that choice simply because it feels like the right thing to do. Nearly half of children under three are still cared for only by their parents, while many others are cared for by relatives. Surveys show that most mothers do not want to work full-time while their children are young; they would prefer to remain at home or work part time or work flexible hours. For many, the arrangements they have are not the arrangements they want. In the aftermath of the Columbine massacre, many Americans saw the tragedy as a sign parents were not spending enough time with their children and so did not know what they were really up to.

“Forced” separation of babies from their mothers is not only hard on the babies, it’s hard on mothers too. Diagnoses of major depression are increasing in women. Neuroscientist and psychologist Richard J. Davidson6 reported on data from the years 2013 to 2016 showing a thirty-three percent increase in women’s depression—in just three years.7

Of course there are lots of reasons people become depressed. But for those who do decide to have a family, the struggle to reconcile self-development and mothering does not suggest women are feeling freer or happier. It is safe to say that since mothers of young children have also been expected to work outside of the home, life for many women has become much more stressful. Many complain they feel a tremendous sense of guilt and frustration, not having the time or energy to do their jobs or raise their children as well as they think they could if they could focus on one or the other. Regarding parenting these days, in 2024, U.S. Surgeon General Dr. Vivek Murthy issued the nation’s first Surgeon General’s Advisory devoted specifically to parental mental health and well-being, stating, “The stress and mental health challenges faced by parents can take a steep toll.”8

So now we have come to a time when having a baby is as much a cause for concern as it is a cause for celebration. Parenting in this culture is like walking through a minefield. Many parents feel they have lost control. They do not feel able to pass on their beliefs and values or raise their children the way they would want to. Indeed, children being raised in daycare by non-relatives can be seen as living in a valueless abyss. Parents spend so little time with them that it is difficult to teach manners and values, while daycare workers, who spend many hours with them each day, cannot realistically provide each child with the moral guidance that is the responsibility of the family. And so, as a society, we increasingly see the problem of children, and even adults; yes, children do grow up, who lack an even basic understanding of how to conduct themselves with consideration for others. This much dissatisfaction, depression, dysfunction, and even death in the worst cases might lead one to wonder why we don’t see more people questioning the logic of separating babies from their mothers when they are so young, and obviously so dependent.

When we think of other animals it seems clear it would not make sense to separate offspring from their mothers too early. If someone started a practice of taking still-nursing puppies whose eyes hadn’t even opened yet away from their mothers—sending them off with a makeshift bottle, formula, and a message of good luck, hope things turn out alright—they would promptly be arrested for animal cruelty. And when we look at other mammals with high intelligence such as elephants, dolphins, whales, and chimpanzees, we see they require longer bonding times with their mothers, all taking years to grow their complex brains. In the wild, the mother and her young always stay together during the period of dependence unless forced apart by some unavoidable misfortune like the untimely death of the mother, for example. Chimpanzees spend about five years nursing, “and remain close to their mothers for the first decade of their lives.”9

So the question remains: when researching possible explanations for our children’s serious mental health decline—for problems ranging from ADHD to suicide and school shootings—how could something so natural and logical escape notice or mention in the popular culture? Parents expecting a child, or anyone searching for answers, will be hard-pressed to find any mention of the mother-child bond, or the suggestion that perhaps our practice of early separation may be at the root of a significant portion of these problems. As suggested earlier, and as will be explained in some detail later, those with ideological, political and economic agendas—the culture creators in the universities and the media—have carefully shaped the discussion so that certain ideas, like “babies need their mothers,” have become taboo and off limits. As Brian C. Robertson, then a research fellow at the Family Research Council’s Center for Marriage and Family declared more than two decades ago:

Today we see in academia … intellectual inconsistencies and intolerance of dissent in the debate – or lack of it – over institutional day care. A sweeping social experiment with profound consequences for young children and their families has been pushed beyond the reach of open and honest discussion.10

There is such a concern that the hard-won gains for women will be lost if we start talking about how necessary they are to the healthy development of their babies the subject can never come up. The focus is on her as a woman—not a mother—her ambitions, her need to develop herself, her need for quality daycare so she can be free to be all she can be. Her role in her child’s life is seen as only one of many, and she is not necessarily more important. In fact, in much of the modern academic literature and the popular media, the term “mother” has been replaced with “primary caregiver” and in some contexts even giving birth no longer makes her a mother, but a “birthing person.” And, should anyone dare to point out the obvious—that a mother is not merely an interchangeable caregiver—the censure is swift and merciless. Psychoanalyst and clinical social worker Erica Komisar, author of Being There: Why Prioritizing Motherhood in the First Three Years Matters, says:

I know this issue is a very controversial one—so controversial, in fact, that few dare to address it. … Clinicians are reluctant to make direct correlations publicly between an emotionally disengaged or physically absent mother and a child’s personality, social functioning and even mental illness, but it’s what we discuss as clinicians among ourselves.11

It is astonishing to think that we live in a society where stating that a baby needs its mother to develop in a healthy way could be considered controversial. But this is the reality that’s been created.

Psychologists looking for answers to the myriad problems plaguing our youth look within a framework of politically correct variables—variables that can be seen mostly as symptoms, such as social isolation or exposure to media violence, rather than causes, of the fundamental problem that can never be mentioned. The mother-infant bond has become like the evil villain in the Harry Potter series, Lord Voldemort—that which must not be named. And so, with each new tragedy, a reasonable explanation remains elusive. In news coverage following the mass shootings in El Paso, Texas, and Dayton, Ohio, which occurred within thirteen hours of each other in August 2019, we see examples of “explanations” that range from inane to ludicrous. Speaking about possible causes in a news conference, Texas governor Greg Abbott made the comment, “Bottom line is mental health is a large contributor to any type of violence or shooting violence,”12 echoed by media commentators,13 while local sheriff briefings offered orthogonal administrative assessments.14

To summarize the problem, we have created a culture around childcare that encourages mothers to leave their babies, sometimes as early as two weeks, often in commercial facilities, for sometimes as long as fifty hours per week. Motherhood is demeaned, and women who stay home with their babies are seen as somehow less than their working counterparts. The pressure on new mothers to work is so great the situation can exist where a minimum wage worker must leave her baby to go earn the money to pay for another minimum wage worker to take care of her baby in a daycare center. Or a professional therapist has to leave her infant in daycare to provide therapy to children who are struggling as a result of being left too early as babies. Not only can the insanity of such a practice not be overstated, the situation is so deleterious to the healthy development of our children an alien force determined to ruin our society could not have devised a better plan. We have indeed created a Daycare Nightmare.

But how do we know any of this is true? What evidence is there to support what may seem like an outlandish, far-fetched theory? Is there sound scientific evidence to support the idea that separation of mothers and babies during the first years of life could actually be tearing apart the very foundations of our society’s mental health? Fortunately the answer is a resounding yes. Even before we as a culture decided this dangerous practice was a good idea, the scientific understanding of attachment was taking shape.

Psychoanalysts and developmental psychologists were eventually joined by neuroscientists, all helping us understand why a secure, dependable relationship is necessary for healthy brain development. And then there are the psychoneuroendocrinologists who study hormones and the effects of early stress on healthy emotional development. And on it goes: researchers across varied disciplines creating studies that approach the problem from different angles and add more and more pieces to the puzzle, bringing the picture into sharper focus as time goes on. Speaking of pictures coming into sharper focus, advances in brain-imaging technology now allow us to see patterns of brain activity associated with mother-infant interactions, and, with newer hyperscanning methods, to observe their brains synchronizing in real time.15

Researchers around the world have been working on these questions for decades. Many believe enough is now known to declare without reservation that, regarding the foundations of emotional regulation and mental health laid in the first years of life, loving maternal presence is protective and maternal separation is a powerful risk factor. But how many new parents know any of this? Where is the information they need to make that all-important decision regarding who will care for their new baby? How many know just how critical that first attachment relationship is for the healthy emotional development of their child? Who among us understands that what happens in the life of the baby from birth until age three lays the foundation for a happy, emotionally connected life—or the opposite—depending on the care that is given to, and taken with, that complex little being? And who knows just how vital a strong, dependable, joyful attachment figure is for the development of a personality that is strong, dependable, and joyful?

Those questions and their answers are the reason this book was written. The goal was to provide historical context and tell the story of how we arrived here from both a cultural and a scientific perspective. To create a comprehensive framework for understanding this complex and important issue, Daycare Nightmare takes a deep dive into several related topics. Together, they reveal both how our cultural values have shaped current practices surrounding infant and toddler care and what scientific research tells us babies actually require for healthy emotional growth and development. They include:

  • ethnographic descriptions of child-rearing among indigenous peoples;
  • the neurobiology of early brain development and a biological explanation of the mother-infant bonding process;
  • the history of attachment theory;
  • the use of attachment theory in psychological research;
  • the influence of the feminist movement and societal forces that led mothers to leave their babies and toddlers to work outside the home;
  • the harsh reality for mothers and babies living within this new cultural script;
  • the neurobiology of healthy emotional development;
  • an explanation of how early mother-infant separation may lay the foundation for future mental dysfunction;
  • ADHD and other downstream consequences;
  • attachment disorder as a potential foundational precursor to school shooter type violence using the life of Dylan Klebold as a case study; and
  • a path forward toward health and wholeness.

Our story begins at the beginning in Chapter Two which examines child rearing among human groups that still live as hunters and gatherers. These cultures provide our closest glimpse into how human beings lived and raised their children for most of our history as a species, offering a valuable reference point for considering how modern childcare practices may differ in potentially harmful ways. Chapter Three describes the astronomical brain growth that happens from the last trimester of pregnancy through the second year and the processes whereby Mother Nature facilitates the bonding process. A beautiful dance of mind and heart synchrony unfolds between mother and child when they are supported and allowed to remain together and form a strong secure attachment. It is vital for the healthy emotional development of the baby and forms the foundation for all future healthy relationships. Chapter Four provides historical context for the work of John Bowlby and Mary Ainsworth and the birth of attachment theory. Chapter Five shows how developmental psychologists used attachment theory to gain important insights relating to personality development and the enduring importance of our earliest attachment relationships in building resilience for life’s challenges. Featured prominently is the work of Dr. Alan Sroufe and the Minnesota Longitudinal Study, which began more than fifty years ago and continues to yield important insights today. Chapter Six provides historical context for the second wave feminist movement, which emerged in the 1960s and radically changed society’s expectations for women and mothers. It examines the influence of Betty Friedan and The Feminine Mystique as important catalysts for that transformation. Chapter Seven focuses on the personal nightmare created for mothers and their babies as they attempt to follow a new cultural script that requires them to live largely separate lives. Chapter Eight provides a detailed explanation of the neuroscience of attachment and the requirements for developing healthy emotional regulation. This information supplies the necessary background for considering how separation and insecure attachment may instead contribute to emotional dysregulation. The chapter then takes a detailed look at ADHD as a potential environmental consequence rather than strictly a genetic anomaly. It concludes with a discussion of other possible consequences of the nightmare—including depression, anxiety, addiction, and suicide—which together contribute to what is increasingly being described as an epidemic of mental illness in our society. Chapter Nine uses the life of Columbine killer Dylan Klebold as a case study to develop a theory of how insecure attachment might lay the foundation for such extreme and violent behavior. Finally, Chapter Ten proposes a path forward toward health and wholeness for individual families and society as a whole. It is my belief that only when we recognize how this issue affects us all, can we summon the unified national will necessary for change—and, most important, believe that we can wake up from our culturally created Daycare Nightmare.


Footnotes & Endnotes

Footnotes

a. Certainly not all psychologists in this field. ↩︎

b. Percentage statistics based on estimated population of approximately 60 million U.S. children. ↩︎

Endnotes

1. Meng, J.F. & Wiznitzer, E. (2024). “Factors Associated with Not Receiving Mental Health Services among Children with a Mental Disorder in Early Childhood in the United States, 2021-2022.” Preventing Chronic Disease, 21, 240126. https://doi.org/10.5888/pcd21.240126 ↩︎

2. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2026, July 8). “Data on ADHD in Children.” https://www.cdc.gov/children-mental-health/data-research/index.html ↩︎

3. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2025, June 5). “Data and Statistics on Children’s Mental Health.” https://www.cdc.gov/children-mental-health/data-research/index.html ↩︎

4. Lauren D. Garfield et al., “Psychotropic Use Among Preschool Children in the Medicaid Program From 36 States,” American Journal of Public Health 105, no. 3 (2015): 524–529, https://doi.org/10.2105/AJPH2014.302258. ↩︎

5. PathwaysConnect, “Dr. Gabor Maté on Attachment and Conscious Parenting,” 1:26–2:13, August 15, 2011, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_tdljIW86e8. ↩︎

6. Richard J. Davidson, TEDxSanFrancisco talk, “How Mindfulness Changes the Emotional Life of Our Brains,” October 2019, 6:26–6:45. ↩︎

7. Ibid., 6:30–6:45 (years referenced: 2013–2016). ↩︎

8. U.S. Surgeon General, Parents Under Pressure: The U.S. Surgeon General’s Advisory on the Mental Health and Well-Being of Parents, August 2024. ↩︎

9. Project R&R, “Chimpanzee Society,” June 26, 2021 (citing Jane Goodall Institute, “Tool Use, Hunting, and Other Discoveries”), https://releasechimps.org/chimpanzees/chimpanzee-society. ↩︎

10. Brian C. Robertson, Day Care Deception: What the Child Care Establishment Isn’t Telling Us (San Francisco: Encounter Books, 2003), 41. ↩︎

11. Erica Komisar, Being There: Why Prioritizing Motherhood in the First Three Years Matters (New York: Penguin, 2017), xiv–xv. ↩︎

12. Marcela Gaviria, “Targeting El Paso,” FRONTLINE, WGBH Educational Foundation, January 7, 2020, 4:16–4:23, https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/frontline/film/targeting-el-paso/. ↩︎

13. Todd Garrin, “‘Fox & Friends’ co-hosts link ‘video games,’ ‘parenting’ to recent mass shootings: ‘There’s so many different factors,’” Yahoo! Entertainment, June 26, 2021, https://www.yahoo.com/entertainment/fox-and-friends-cohosts-link-video-games-parenting-to-recent-mass-shootings-theres-so-many-different-factors-211028512.html. ↩︎

14. Volusia Sheriff’s Office, “Media briefing on deputy-involved shooting: 6/1/21,” Facebook, 14:45–14:49, June 1, 2021, https://www.facebook.com/VolusiaSheriff/videos/118264550379763; ibid., 16:12–16:17. ↩︎

15. Yasuyo Minagawa et al., “Inter-brain Synchrony during Mother-infant Interactive Parenting in 3-4-Month-old infants with and without an Elevated Likelihood of Autism Spectrum Disorder,” Cerebral Cortex 33, no. 24 (2023): 11609–11622, https://doi.org/10.1093/cercor/bhad395. ↩︎