Awareness is the greatest agent for change.
—Eckhart Tolle
⁓
Much of the information presented in this book may seem shocking—even unbelievable—to many. How could the local daycare center be a place of neglect and a factory for the creation of childhood mental illness, echoing in some ways the early twentieth-century orphanage? As a child of the ‘60s, a mother, sociologist, and teacher, I have witnessed a pervasive and alarming deterioration in our society’s mental health over my lifetime. From my perspective the foundational problem is clear: the separation of babies from their mothers.
The rise of feminist ideology, the influence of the daycare lobby, and the economic push for women’s participation in the workforce have all contributed to the promotion of a dangerous idea: that babies don’t really need their mothers, and that mothers have more important things to do with their time than be “slaves to domesticity.” Whether new moms believe this or not, every mother has to deal with our anti-mother cultural reality that was largely shaped by the second wave feminist movement. Now, the majority of mothers with children under three are employed, either full- or part-time and as a result, most American babies are being cared for by someone other than their mothers for much of the day. Many are placed in commercial daycare.
If it’s true—as many have been led to believe—that the developmental needs of babies can be met from time spent in daycare, then why is it that so many of us now know a family, perhaps even our own, with at least one struggling child? When we look at the dramatic changes of the past sixty years in maternal employment and the widespread placement of infants in daycare, I suggest these cultural shifts and the decline in the mental health of our children are more than coincidental.
As Gabor Maté, physician, best-selling author, and trauma specialist has said, “If you look at childhood in North America right now, we can see that it’s seriously under threat.”1 The rising rates of childhood distress range from an inability to concentrate in school, to depression, anxiety, self-harm, child and teen suicide, and, at the extreme, the horrific phenomenon of young people who take firearms to school, kill their classmates, and then in many cases take their own lives. These kinds of tragedies now happen so often that there’s the danger of seeing them as a normal part of modern life rather than as shocking anomalies; just the way things are or have to be.
The ideas for this book have been forming for years but the decision to go ahead and write it came as I was watching the Democratic primary debates in early 2020. A general theme emerged: our nation is coming apart at the seams. The usual issues and standard solutions were batted around, but our deepening mental health crisis – and its possible causes—were predictably absent. Certainly no one was discussing the possibility that separating babies from their mothers may be cause for concern. For over six decades, we’ve been told mothers should return to work soon after childbirth and that babies are resilient. This narrative has been so thoroughly promoted that few question it, and we remain the only industrialized nation without federally guaranteed maternity leave. Instead of any discussion even hinting at the possibility of government responsibility for helping mothers who want to care for their own babies, what we heard on that debate stage was Elizabeth Warren pushing hard for universal government-funded daycare from birth to age five.2
Yet Quebec, Canada, had already provided a cautionary example, having introduced a similar government-funded program in 1997. Studies examining the program’s effects identified serious negative consequences, including increases in aggression, hyperactivity, and anxiety among children. These problems persisted into the school years, and as the children grew older, researchers found lower life satisfaction and higher rates of criminal behavior among those who participated in the program. The research also revealed troubling consequences for families, including significant increases in maternal depression, lower-quality parent-child relationships, and marital dissatisfaction.3
The moment I heard Warren vehemently advocating for this policy, I went into panic mode, knowing in my heart such a policy would be disastrous for our children and families. At the time, however, I knew nothing about the troubling findings from Quebec. My strong beliefs were mostly based on a mother’s intuition and my teaching experience working with struggling students and their families, but also on anthropological studies of indigenous cultures practicing more natural forms of child rearing. My life experience and education had led to an absolute conviction that mothers and babies should be together in those first critical years. But was there actual scientific research to back up those convictions? It was then that I set out on a mission to find out all I could across disciplines to answer that question: just how important is a strong bond between mother and baby for healthy development, with baby defined as the time from birth to age three? And related to that, how necessary is it that the two spend their days and nights together during that time? A compelling story emerged, one I believed needed to be told. And that is how this book, Daycare Nightmare, came to be.
Before going any further, here’s some background about me.
I started attending the University of South Florida at age seventeen and I loved it so much I just kept going. The result was many years of coursework and several degrees. Though, perhaps surprisingly, none of those degrees are in child development. I first majored in sociology because I had always been intrigued with the workings of society. After earning a master’s degree in sociology I entered a doctoral program in a related discipline, applied anthropology. Just as I had finished all coursework and qualifying exams and was organizing my doctoral research on single mothers in Costa Rica, life intervened. I dropped everything to take over the full-time care of my three-year-old niece, Gail. I had planned to start a family after completing the doctorate, but since we were already parenting, we decided to go ahead and try for a child of our own. Gail’s little brother Haakon (pronounced hawk-en) was born eighteen months later. Caring for Gail taught me a great deal about the challenges of raising a child as an adoptive mother and those lessons undoubtedly inform this work. However, I will not reference those experiences directly, out of respect for my sister’s privacy. Gail’s absence from these pages should not be interpreted as an absence of her from my heart—she is still very much my daughter—and Haakon’s sister.
As life unfolded, mothering Gail and Haakon and later volunteering in local schools, I began to realize my interests had shifted. I loved teaching young children and decided to return to school, this time working toward a master’s degree in education. I took classes slowly, knowing that by the time the kids were older, I would be ready to enter a new career. Even as I poured myself into raising the little people who would ultimately shape the meaning of my life, I was quietly planning for what might come next. I did eventually teach preschool and third grade and found it every bit as satisfying as I had imagined. It also gave me firsthand knowledge of students with ADHD characteristics.
As important as my educational background and teaching experience are for a project like this, more important, and what makes it my life’s passion is my experience of motherhood. From the time I can remember I wanted to be a mother and that desire was constantly in the background guiding my life choices. Additionally, I always had a fascination with babies. Frankly, I still do.
As I prepared for motherhood I immersed myself in beautiful books like Joseph Chilton Pearce’s Magical Child,4 which describes the dance of growth and bonding between a mother and her baby. The Womanly Art of Breastfeeding5 was invaluable in giving me the confidence I needed to nurse my son. Breastfeeding laid the foundation for what I would later learn was called “attachment parenting,” a philosophy championed by pediatrician William Sears and his wife, nurse and lactation consultant, and mother of eight, Martha Sears.6 In truth, I was becoming an attachment parent without having read a single book about it—or even having heard the phrase.
All I knew was that once I laid eyes on my baby, I couldn’t separate from him. I remember begging the nurse to let me keep him in the hospital bed with me. “Okay, if you’re careful, but don’t tell anyone, I could get in trouble.” I was so grateful. Then, when Haakon was six months old, we had gotten tickets to a Rod Stewart concert, fully expecting to leave him with a qualified babysitter. When the time came to hand him over, I just couldn’t do it. So along he came, nursed, and slept through the entire thing.
Haakon was born in 1993 and by that time the idea that mothers of young children should work had generally become accepted in our culture. While I was home with my son all of the time there was a much different reality being lived out by families all around us. I was horrified to think of mothers being forced by cultural norms or economic necessity to leave their infants in daycare in order to return to work. I had an intuitive sense it was not healthy for mothers and babies to be separated when the babies were still so young; even though the main message being spread through the media and university classrooms was there was no cause for concern. Despite such comforting reassurance, it was also about this same time it seemed the alphabet soup of children’s mental diagnoses started popping up everywhere: ADD, OCD, ADHD. It was also increasingly common for parents to use phrases like, “My child is on the autism spectrum,” as if it had become such a normal part of childhood we were supposed to know what that meant. And so it was that the foundation for our Daycare Nightmare had been established and was already firmly in place.
Fast forward three decades. As I dug into the research for this project with the aim of finding out what is truly known regarding that all-important question: how critical is the mother’s love and presence for her baby’s healthy development, a fascinating story unfolded with an interesting cast of characters you’ll meet in upcoming pages. As it turned out, just as the main tenets of attachment theory were being tested and validated,a the feminist movement was gaining momentum. What started as a push to breakdown stereotypes and give women more choices ended up pushing mothers of young children to work outside of the home and so ironically limiting their choice to raise their own infants and toddlers.
Most everyone would agree important and valuable changes have occurred that have freed women and men from restrictive stereotypes. I count myself among those and I am grateful for the opportunities I have enjoyed personally and professionally as a result. But the goals of the feminist movement and the changes it wrought did not adequately or honestly take into account the impact two working parents would have on young children, particularly babies under three. And the drive to promote the interests of women apart from those of their partners and children has had the unintended result of actually pitting mothers’ interests against those of their children.
The idea that mothers should work in the paid economy, which is firmly established now, puts women in an impossible bind because taking care of an infant is more than a full-time job in itself. So to do it well and to also do another job on top of that, especially a full-time job, means there must be compromise because, unfortunately, mothers of babies are not afforded 48 hours a day to do all that must be done. This impossible situation that has been created for women, all with the intended goal of making their lives better, has led to dangerous ideas about what babies require for healthy development. Additionally, this unnatural cultural bind has led to a cascade of dysfunctional adjustments, affecting mothers and babies, and ultimately our broader society in profound ways.
Before going on, I need to clearly state my position. It is not my intention to try to push cultural norms back to the ‘50’s with mothers in their kitchens and aprons until the kids are grown and out of the house. Cultural evolution moves forward and so, even if we wanted to, we can’t go back. But who would want to? We now live in a time when women have unprecedented possibilities for personal growth and development. But life is long, and women need to have the time and support to develop their nurturing capacities along with other skills and talents, and to raise their babies themselves if they so choose, without having to compromise their career success. Once that stage of life has passed and their children have a healthy emotional foundation upon which to build their lives, a world of other endeavors becomes possible. This forced choice of career or child-rearing in the early years is cruel and socially constructed. It doesn’t have to be this way, and it shouldn’t, for reasons that will be illuminated in the following pages.
Babies are those citizens who have no political voice and no way to advocate for themselves. They depend on cultural mores based on an understanding of their dependence, their vulnerability, and the absolute necessity of their healthy development for the health of society in general. We as a people have gotten ourselves on a course that disregards all of this and I suggest our current practices surrounding parenting and child-rearing are not leading to the increased happiness and contentment of mothers. In reality the opposite is true. Aside from the pressure of impossible demands on their time and energy, living with the reality of a child or more than one, who is suffering, struggling, or worse is indeed a nightmare that more and more mothers are living with. And what of the millions of innocent children struggling with brains shaped by societal conditions that have set them up for failure and enduring mental health problems?
My goal in writing Daycare Nightmare is to provide objective, scientifically supported information that will help us take off our blinders, think clearly about what the evidence reveals, and find a path, both personally and as a society, back to a place of health and wholeness. A disclaimer is in order here: this book has a definite pro-mother bias. You will not see the term primary caregiver, and that is intentional. I believe our anti-mother culture has demeaned the role of the biological mother and promoted the idea that pretty much anyone will do. The word mother itself has increasingly become a subject of controversy, with some institutions replacing it with gender-neutral terms in the name of inclusivity. I find this troubling, particularly when discussing pregnancy, childbirth, breastfeeding, and the unique biological relationship between mothers and their babies. Throughout this book, I have deliberately chosen to use the word mother, and I make no apology for doing so.
This choice should not be interpreted as diminishing the importance of fathers, grandparents, adoptive parents, foster parents, and others in the lives of children who need love and nurturing. I am an adoptive mother myself. The point is to help reverse the cultural conditions that can make it difficult for mothers to be the best they could be, only to have society point its collective finger at them and say, “See, we told you mothers cannot always be counted on to provide the best care to their own children.”
Mothers and their young children have been under attack for decades through policies that separate them when children are youngest and most dependent, and through the dangerous ideology that caregivers are interchangeable. I particularly want to speak to fathers and say, of course you are important to your babies from the very beginning. The focus on the unique relationship that nature created between mother and infant does not in any way diminish your importance. But it is true that fathers play more of a supporting role early on, helping provide what mothers need to be physically and emotionally available to their babies. As children grow, fathers have opportunities to take on more a central role in their daily lives. Teamwork is what it’s all about, and understanding the importance of the mother-infant relationship in the beginning can help give children the healthiest possible start in life.
More specifically, the purpose of this book is threefold:
1. To trace the historical events that led us to where we are; explore the development and significance of attachment theory; and examine the scientific evidence from a variety of disciplines supporting the importance of keeping mothers and babies together during the critical early years.
2. To support and promote a mother’s choice to stay with her infant or toddler and be the primary caregiver, as nature intended, while helping families support mothers in that all-important work.
3. To change the national understanding of the importance of mothers and families to the healthy development of young children, especially infants and toddlers; to raise mothering in the national consciousness to the position of high status it deserves; and to provide information that can help build a unified national will for paid maternity leave for every mother who chooses to stay home during the critical years from birth to age three.
This book is written for:
- Families struggling with the decision of whether mom should return to work after their baby is born.
- Women who are home caring for their child but wondering whether they’ve made the right decision. Does their full-time presence really matter?
- Families who want to raise healthy children and understand more about the possible causes of our childhood mental health epidemic before the damage is done.
- Families who are looking for possible explanations for why their child is having mental health issues beyond the genetic explanation that boils down to, “it was the luck of the draw.”
- All members of our society, especially policymakers who care about the health of our children and the future of our country.
Our “dangerous experiment”7 with daycare has gone on long enough that it is time to set aside political differences and corporate agendas to do what is right for babies, mothers, families, and ultimately the health and future of our nation. I am adding my voice to the many psychologists, psychiatrists, neuroscientists, doctors, therapists, teachers, and social workers who are sounding the alarm and whose fine work provides the intellectual foundation for the story that unfolds on these pages.
It is my greatest hope that you will add your voice, too.
Footnotes & Endnotes
Footnote
a. Yes, mom is critically important. ↩︎
Endnotes
1. PathwaysConnect, “Dr. Gabor Maté on Attachment and Conscious Parenting,” August 15, 2011, YouTube video, 0:10–0:19, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_tdljIW86e8&t=10s. ↩︎
2. ABC News, “Democratic Presidential Candidates Debate in New Hampshire,” ABC News Live, February 7, 2020, YouTube video, 37:22–37:26, https://www.youtube.com/live/_JCTY6MxJ4I?t=2242s. ↩︎
3. Michael Baker, Jonathan Gruber, and Kevin Milligan, “Universal Child Care, Maternal Labor Supply, and Family Well-Being,” Journal of Political Economy 116, no. 4 (2008): 709–745, https://doi.org/10.1086/591908; Michael Baker, Jonathan Gruber, and Kevin Milligan, “The Long-Run Impacts of a Universal Child Care Program,” American Economic Journal: Economic Policy 11, no. 3 (2019): 1–26, https://doi.org/10.1257/pol.20170603. ↩︎
4. Joseph Chilton Pearce, Magical Child (New York: E. P. Dutton, 1992). ↩︎
5. La Leche League International, The Womanly Art of Breastfeeding, 5th rev. ed. (Franklin Park, IL: La Leche League International, 1993). ↩︎
6. William Sears and Martha Sears, The Attachment Parenting Book: A Commonsense Guide to Understanding and Nurturing Your Baby (Boston: Little, Brown and Company, 2001). ↩︎
7. Brian C. Robertson, Day Care Deception: What the Child Care Establishment Isn’t Telling Us (San Francisco: Encounter Books, 2003). ↩︎