The Nightmare Begins
We cannot train our babies not to need us. Whether it’s the middle of the day or the middle of the night, their needs are real and valid, including the simple need for human touch. A “trained” baby may give up on his needs being met, but the need is still there, just not the trust.
—L. R. Knost
Don’t stand unmoving outside the door of a crying baby whose only desire is to touch you. Go to your baby. Go to your baby a million times. Demonstrate that people can be trusted, that the environment can be trusted, that we live in a benign universe.
—Peggy O’Mara
If we have no peace, it is because we have forgotten that we belong to each other.
—Mother Teresa
⁓
Some kids are more sensitive than others and can be hurt more if forced to separate from their moms too early. My son was like that. He was born with a predisposition toward social anxiety. His grandmother had it and so did his father and his began to show up at about age three.
As noted previously, I took him everywhere and we were quite social—out visiting and running errands. But once he was old enough to voice his preference, he didn’t want to go anymore. He hated birthday parties. I would try to bribe him into going by telling him I would let him have cake—a special treat since we didn’t eat much sugar—and still no deal. He was happiest at home with his family.
When it came time for school he started at a neighborhood nursery school when he was four. He went mornings three days a week, and that worked out fine. Then it was off to public school for kindergarten and first grade. All seemed to be going okay until second grade, when he got an extremely strict, angry teacher, and we decided to homeschool.
As a professor, my husband had lots of time at home, and as a graduate student, so did I. We were very fortunate to have the opportunity to become Haakon’s teachers. As he started spending his full days back at home, he became noticeably calmer. Only then did I see that he had been developing coping strategies to deal with the anxiety that came naturally to him while being at school with large groups of people.
The reason I’m including this story is because I believe that had my son been forced to separate from me as an infant, with his built‑in predisposition to be anxious around strangers, his brain would not have developed in the healthy way that it did, and our family would have become another statistic in our growing Daycare Nightmare.
Instead, through the years, come what may, right or wrong, Haakon grew up in a secure nest—valued, heard, and understood—in the same way my mom had valued me. He knew we always had his back and that his worth as an individual was never in question.
There’s much talk these days about how it takes a village to raise a child, and boy, could I have used some help in those early years just to catch my breath. I especially wished my mom had been there with me. But I know if a child has at least one person who can always be counted on to be there and to value them no matter what, it’s enough. It’s not the number of relationships that matters most—although more loving relationships are certainly gifts—but the depth and reliability of the primary relationship.
My mother’s steadfast love is what always got me through, and, as you will see, I was able to do the same for my son when the going got really tough. We all need one person—our person—to provide the rock‑solid emotional foundation we can return to and gain strength from again and again as we grow and encounter life’s challenges, which are sure to come.
And with that foundation in place, our children can then become adults with the capacity to form a trusting relationship with the person who will become their significant other. That person then takes our place as their person and together they can provide a secure nest for the next generation, should they decide to take on the immense responsibility of becoming parents—as nature intended.
⁓
What exactly is the Daycare Nightmare—the title of this book and a concept alluded to throughout? It is a broad and complex phenomenon encompassing the circumstances that can lead to the physical and/or emotional separation of babies from their mothers—the distress that separation can cause, the mental scars it can leave, and the consequences that can follow children into adulthood.
The circumstances can range from a mother who is anxious or discouraged and unable to attune to the needs of her baby, to a mother who leaves her infant in a commercial daycare center for ten hours a day. This chapter will reveal the real‑life consequences for babies and mothers living out this unnatural parenting script that is so common these days.
The following chapter will delve more deeply into the neurobiology of secure attachment, showing how early separation can contribute to insecure attachment. From there, we will look at some of the most prevalent downstream outcomes for children and adults, as well as some of the worst. These are problems that may have begun in infancy when the baby was enduring separations its emotional system was never developmentally equipped to handle.
Parenting in America—and around the world, wherever modern, materialistic culture reigns or is aspired to—has become a minefield, with the potential for disaster built into the system. As previously discussed, families living in poverty have long endured stressful conditions that often required parents to leave their children to make a living. The harshest and cruelest example in our nation’s history was slavery, when families could be torn apart at the auction block.
Middle‑class mothers, by contrast, could generally count on being able to care for their own babies. The culture encouraged this arrangement as both natural and good, and under ordinary circumstances, no one questioned it. We now live in a time when that is no longer the case and growing healthy children takes exceptional insight, commitment, and resources that are not provided by our society, nor reinforced through cultural norms. In fact, practices that are working in direct opposition to healthy development are promoted and justified as the new and better way.
Like a poison gas that no one can smell, an anti‑baby, anti‑mothering sentiment has seeped into every part of our society, and every woman who decides to become a mother has to deal with it in one way or another. Over the last five decades, as more and more mothers entered the workforce, the decision of whether to work outside of the home gradually changed from a choice into an expectation. Women no longer felt that it was enough to “just” stay home with their children.
What do you do?
Oh, I’m just a stay‑at‑home mom.
Hence the mommy wars that raged in the 1980s and 1990s, pitting working mothers trying to be Superwomen against those who “only” cared for their families. As this change was taking place, many husbands were more than happy for their wives to arrange child care and help out with the ever‑increasing living expenses. How could they have known it might not be such a good thing for their young children to be separated from their mothers in some sort of other‑care arrangement? After all, everyone was doing it.
So now, when a woman finds out she is expecting, the assumption is she will find child care so she can continue with the life she had before becoming a mother—even if her family has the resources to allow her to stay home. If she wants to stay home and take care of her baby herself, she has to defend that choice against cultural norms that expect her to continue working to keep contributing to the family budget, to maintain her status as an important person, to show her children she is somebody besides just their mother, to help acquire more material goods, nicer vacations, college educations. You name it. There are so many “important” reasons why she should leave her baby and keep working.
And if she wonders if that’s a healthy choice for her child, as we know from the last chapter, everywhere she turns she is reassured: Sure, it’s fine. It’s what modern, ambitious women do these days. If you can afford a good daycare center, go for it. It’s another way to show you’ve made it in our society. You don’t have to stay home, exhausted and bored out of your mind.
Plus, we all know kids are resilient, and daycare is good for them. They can get a leg up on their cognitive skills at the “learning academy.” In fact, when I asked ChatGPT whether daycare is a good choice for infants—meaning babies twelve months old and younger—the “benefits” it outlined included socialization, structure, exposure to diversity, and preparation for school. These are all experiences that may enhance the lives of some preschoolers. But they have absolutely no value and may actually be harmful to an infant who just needs to nestle into the arms of a loving mother.
For those moms who cannot afford daycare—or even for those who make the conscious choice to take care of their own babies—there is still this idea they are not as important in our society as those women who manage to do it all. Motherhood has been demeaned while working mothers are glorified.
As more women have moved into the world of work outside the home and gained more status as participants in the paid economy, they have steadily lost status as mothers who could be considered the experts in the care of their own children. This has undermined the confidence of new mothers and reinforced the notion that a mother is no better equipped to care for her own baby than any other “caregiver.”
Taking care of home and children, once considered the noblest of occupations, came to be viewed as domestic servitude—work done by women with no other options. As with any difficult endeavor, the beliefs a woman has about the importance and status of her job as a mother are critical in shaping how she will experience the exhausting demands of a new baby.
Without the support every mother needs to believe in the absolute importance of what she is doing, even mothers who are physically present with their infants may feel bad about themselves and tune out, finding distractions to help them endure their “imprisonment” rather than relishing this critical time in their baby’s development.
And for those who do have a choice whether to work outside the home, what they have been led to see as sheer drudgery—lacking in status, not to mention money—may lead them to abandon the cause, find child care, and go back to work. And, of course, some women have been so thoroughly convinced that to stay home with a baby would be a fate almost worse than death that they wouldn’t dream of doing it. For them, daycare is by far the preferred option.a
And this is how the nightmare begins.
Mom is convinced that her loving presence is not all that important to her new baby—or she feels she has no choice—and she makes preparations to leave. All these forces, along with the fact that the U.S. is the only industrialized nation without guaranteed paid maternity leave, drive her away from the one person who is totally dependent upon her and truly needs her to provide the foundation for a good and healthy life.
There are many possible arrangements she can make, from a loving family member—the best option—to a commercial daycare center. The following description of life for a mother and baby who must separate will focus on the latter.
We always hear daycare is a good thing, and that idea is accepted at face value by many in the dominant culture, with few analyzing what life is really like, day‑to‑day, for the mothers and babies living this way. The situation is complex, with many different variables, including attitude of parents, the temperaments of mother and baby, the number of hours they spend apart each day, and the type of care the baby receives. This complexity is often used as a smokescreen to stop critical analysis of what is happening right under our noses.
But there is much we do know and can say with a degree of certainty, based on our knowledge of our evolutionary heritage and research into neurobiology and attachment.
The following description is based on women who are expecting a baby and plan to place their infant in a local daycare center after twelve weeks or so of maternity leave. We will look at typical situations and circumstances that commonly arise from this type of arrangement—one considered normal and healthy in mainstream society and experienced by countless families these days.b
During the last trimester of pregnancy, mom is making final preparations before baby arrives, taking care of lots of details like finishing the nursery, attending a baby shower, and enjoying all the wonderful things that come with a new baby. But she also has to arrange child care for her return to work, which, in developmental terms, will happen almost immediately. Twelve weeks goes very quickly.
So while this should be a time of joyful anticipation, it is also laced with trepidation as she must make the potentially gut‑wrenching decision about who will raise her baby while she is at work all day. Visits to centers are helpful, but ultimately, the decision may come down to what is affordable. Daycare is expensive.
The baby growing inside her is affected by her emotional state, including any stress she may be under. Their bodies are intimately connected.
Before we get into the trauma caused to mother and child as one goes to work and the other goes to daycare, let’s look at some of the insidious conditions embedded in our daycare culture that may lead mom to begin psychologically separating from her baby even before she heads back to work.
As previously explained in Chapter 3, following birth, just as in the womb, mother’s body and presence make up baby’s entire world.c Recall, millions of years of evolution have led her newborn to expect to be held close and breastfed around the clock—and have led mom to expect to be able to nurture her dependent child. In a stress‑free, supportive environment, as mom and babe get to know each other, their heart rhythms and brain activity become coordinated and synchronized, while nature provides a cascade of soothing hormones to allow the two to relax and feel rewarded for being together.
As time goes on, if circumstances allow them to remain together, mother becomes more and more attuned to the needs of her baby. Making sure baby is okay becomes her number‑one priority, and she gets lots of satisfaction from doing it. This strong emotional bond forms a heart connection that will endure for life. Baby feels her devotion and grows in a healthy way. This is secure attachment in the making.
Unfortunately, our modern, materialistic culture not only fails to provide a naturally supportive environment but actively works against this kind of bond. In what Dr. Greer Kirshenbaum, neuroscientist and author of The Nurture Revolution calls ours a “low‑nurture culture,” new moms are instructed to train their babies not to need them. The good baby is a trained baby, and a good mom is geared toward separation. “[Our] low‑nurture culture… erroneously tells us to separate, limit presence, and teach independence; to let them cry it out, not to spoil, to make them self‑soothe.”1
Ironically, this training is sold to parents as the best way to promote healthy infant growth and development. According to this child‑rearing paradigm, babies need and want structure and schedules, and they need to be taught to sleep through the night for enhanced cognitive development. So the new mom, not realizing that none of this is true, is encouraged by our anti‑baby culture to separate not only while she is at work but during the long nights as well, because supposedly all family members thrive on uninterrupted sleep. Instead of comfortably nestling in with her baby for the evening and reconnecting after the long day apart, mom is encouraged to ignore her nurturing impulses and begin the cruel and inhumane training process.
Sleep training is the cornerstone of the baby‑training regimen—and definitely the cruelest. Dr. Richard Ferber is perhaps the most well‑known proponent with his method known as “Ferberizing” the baby. He tells parents to put their babyd in another room away from them and quietly leave. When the baby cries out, parents are supposed to ignore the cries for successively longer intervals. When they do go in to comfort the baby, they’re not allowed to pick it up. They are supposed to tell the baby that all is well and leave again.2
For a baby who expects to be held close to mama’s body for warmth, comfort, and feeding—not to mention safety—this is utterly terrifying. Infants cry to signal they are in distress. As the time extends with no one coming their immature brain does not have any way of understanding what is happening because it is so unnatural and signifies extreme danger. All the baby can do is cry more to get the comfort it desperately needs. Then mom or dad comes in only to leave again and this happens repeatedly.
Imagine you’re in a situation that has you completely terrified, you’re screaming for help, and then the person you hope will come to your rescue comes for a moment to tell you everything is fine and then leaves again when you are still fearing for your life. This happens over and over again with you crying more desperately each time.
Some babies will cry out for help for hours until they are completely out of control and vomiting, and still no one comes—or when someone does, they leave again. The desperate baby will finally pass out and get quiet. Sleep training proponents explain that the baby has learned to “self‑soothe.” It’s a comforting thought, but unfortunately infant brains lack the mature prefrontal development needed to regulate intense emotional distress on their own. And even if their brains could do that, who among us chooses to “self soothe” when we are desperately in need of emotional reassurance? No, we reach out for that person we know can comfort us, and when they are there to help us get a handle on the situation we feel better.
If you think about it, the concept of self‑soothing during infancy is completely bogus. No, they aren’t self‑soothing. They’re just exhausted and defeated. They fall asleep cold, alone, and abandoned.
Throughout our evolutionary history a situation like this would only occur under dire circumstances like the death of the mother and the infant would likely die too. The stress of crying for that long leads the newly developing brain to be bathed in stress hormones that may permanently alter brain development and functioning in ways we are just beginning to understand. Under natural conditions parents would never willingly let their infant become that distressed… never!
Yet parents are told this is actually a good thing to do to their baby, when the truth is it is very dangerous, with no benefits and the potential for great harm. Recall John B. Watson, the father of behaviorism, who told parents to withdraw all affection from their children to make them strong and independent. How did he come up with that idea? After seeing a Russian scientist train a dog to salivate at the sound of a bell, Watson decided human children could be trained the same way. He just made it up out of thin air. And people believed him.
After he was kicked out of Johns Hopkins for having an affair with his research assistant while he was married, Watson became a successful advertising executive. He was skilled in the art of salesmanship. At the end of his life he burned all of his written materials and said he regretted what he had done. Watson is gone, but his tragic legacy lives on in the idea that complex human brains can be trained like dogs to suit the needs of adults who are inclined to value the notion of well‑trained children.
And then along comes someone like Richard Ferber, who tells parents it’s a good idea to train babies to sleep alone—another example of someone just making stuff up—“babies can self‑soothe”—and claiming the authority to influence untold numbers of parents who believe he actually knows what he’s talking about.
There are many reasons parents are vulnerable to this kind of advice. Dr. James McKenna has been studying safe infant sleep for over three decades and wrote a book by the same name (2022). He believes one reason is that couples have way fewer children than they used to and no longer live in extended families where everyone routinely saw children being raised. That type of natural education on child‑rearing doesn’t exist anymore in our society. This leads new parents feeling vulnerable and unprepared, with a tendency to rely on professionals who supposedly have their best interests at heart. In many instances the advice goes completely against what seems to make sense intuitively but they follow it anyway.
McKenna explains when he and his wife were expecting their first child they were naturally nervous and eager to do everything right, so they read all of the baby books available at the time. They were surprised to find the “experts’” advice was very different from what their training as anthropologists had led them to believe. Even though they knew from studying other cultures around the world that most of what they were reading seemed unnatural and counterintuitive from an evolutionary perspective they still doubted themselves and went along. They even tried sleep training. In McKenna’s words:
When I was a young parent, before I knew what I know today, my wife and I let my infant son cry it out for about 15 minutes. It remains the only 15 minutes of my life I wish I could take back. It was like torture for my little son, and his feelings of suffering and rejection were completely unwarranted. When I opened the door, he was standing at his crib rail, eyes swollen, sobbing and hyperventilating. I saw only love and relief in his face in seeing me, and my own heart broke.3
Another explanation for being open to advice that may not feel right is the pressure, especially for a working mom, to get life back to normal. She’s getting ready to, or has already returned to work and she knows she needs her sleep to be able to work full time and take care of her infant—a full‑time job in itself. She’s already exhausted from lack of sleep and cannot imagine continuing to work all day after being up half the night and so she agrees to start separating from her infant at night.
The nightmare now begins in earnest for her little one who desperately needs to be with her: long nights away from mom after the long days in daycare. With sleep training in place, the baby will spend the majority of its time away from its mom—the baby’s lifeline—because our society has decided she has more important things to do. This kind of separation causes the rapidly developing infant brain to see the world as unsafe and begin developing coping mechanisms that may form the foundation for future mental illness.
And for some babies separation so early is just too much for their little systems to take and they die. Their parents find them dead in their cribs in the morning.
Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS), or crib death, is rare—about 1300 cases per year in the United States—but for the parents who lose their baby this way, it is an unimaginable tragedy. When they return to the professionals for answers, there are none forthcoming. They throw their hands up in the air and say the situation is just too complex and there is no way to know. Some babies just die for no reason. It is true that a certain number of newborns will have complications that are fatal, but for a healthy baby who has been sent home with its parents, that situation does not apply. Perhaps the answer has something to do with separating from mom too early.
Actually, there is powerful evidence to support that explanation. Human babies have slept beside their mothers since the beginning of time, and in many cultures around the world, they still do. When they are held close, kept warm, comforted, and nursed through the night such care is protective and they don’t die. In fact, SIDS became a known syndrome in the United States during the middle of the last century, when our nation’s affluence allowed families to have separate nurseries. Artificial formula and bottle‑feeding were also promoted at this time. In places where babies still sleep with their mothers, SIDS is practically nonexistent, and people in those cultures see our practice of sleeping separately as cruel—a form of child abuse.
From a scientific perspective, we know that switching from receiving oxygen through an umbilical cord to breathing through lungs can be a difficult transition. As described earlier, when the mother and infant are together their brains and bodies become aligned in rhythmic synchronicity, and the infant can take breathing cues from the mother that help the new respiratory system run efficiently. Research has shown that babies given infant formula sleep more deeply and, if separated from mom, can simply forget to breathe.4 If a baby stops breathing while sleeping with mom, perhaps because of having been fed formula, her presence can save her infant’s life.
In Safe Infant Sleep, Dr. McKenna includes stories from mothers who said their intuition told them something was wrong while they were sleeping beside their infants. They woke to find their babies had stopped breathing and were already turning blue. Because the mothers were right there, they were able to provide the necessary stimulation to get their babies breathing again. Had they not been there, each mother felt sure their child would have died.5
Nevertheless, The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP), the professional organization that researches and recommends best practices for pediatricians, actively warns against bed‑sharing, and pediatricians warn parents that bringing baby into bed with them is a very dangerous thing to do. In hospital maternity wards, “lactation specialists and nurses… are threatened with losing their jobs should they even mention the word co‑sleeping.”6 Why? Because if it is not done thoughtfully, bed‑sharing can result in babies being suffocated, especially when an adult has been drinking or using drugs. Accidents do happen. And in our anti‑baby, anti‑mother culture the absolute necessity of parents—especially mothers—for their infants is downplayed, and parents are instead treated as threats who cannot be trusted to care responsibly for their own children.
There are a few basic instructions that make bed‑sharing much safer, but instead of educating the population and promoting those, they design fear campaigns to scare parents into separating. One such “safe sleep” ad showed a huge butcher knife on a bed next to a baby with the slogan: “Your baby sleeping with you can be just as dangerous!”7 Ironically, mothers who are terrified of bringing baby into bed with them sometimes fall asleep in a recliner or on a couch while feeding in the middle of the night, and those soft, curvy surfaces are dangerous—causing infant deaths from suffocation and strangulation.
The political power of the AAP keeps the voices of sleep researchers who understand the protective benefits of keeping baby with mama at night out of the professional conversation. They use tactics similar to those used in silencing daycare opponents, explained in the last chapter. McKenna points out the AAP’s hard line against mothers and babies sleeping together because accidents can happen is like saying that because people sometimes choke to death on food, we should all stop eating.8 It is not an exaggeration to say that an infant’s need to be close to mom for good health is akin to our need for nutritious food to stay alive and healthy.
It’s alarming to think that pediatricians—the doctors whose specialty it is to help new mothers keep their babies healthy—actively promote detrimental, even life‑threatening, sleep practices. Their anti‑mothering position is what is most dangerous for infants: dangerous in obvious ways, like death from SIDS, and in less obvious ways like setting the infant up for the mental dysfunction that comes from too much maternal separation too early.
As we return to considering the typical life of a mother and infant that will be going their separate ways following a brief maternity leave, we cannot assume the mother engaged in sleep training because the recommended age to begin is older than twelve weeks. She may have even practiced bed‑sharing, keeping her baby with her at night and doing all she could to provide a secure bond before she had to leave.
So what happens to their lives, and the secure attachment that was just beginning to develop when suddenly, one day, mom just up and leaves—when she hands baby over to strangers, people who, in most cases, had not previously been in baby’s home environment? We will first look at the potential trauma such an unnatural situation creates for the infant and then turn to what it does to the mother.
But before delving into those terrible scenarios, let’s briefly consider the concept of “quality daycare,” that catch‑all phrase suggested as baby’s saving grace in almost all literature on the effects of daycare for infants and toddlers—With quality daycare all children will thrive.
So what is “quality daycare” really—that expensive, longed‑for “solution” everyone is always talking about? While it is usually suggested that quality daycare can be purchased in a commercial center with enough money, the truth is that such an arrangement is impossible for infants because quality care for the very young requires the same investment of time and emotional involvement the mother herself would give. The requirements for healthy infant brain development formed through eons of evolution and are non‑negotiable, requiring a caretaker who is consistently present and emotionally available. Anything less has the potential to cause damage to a greater or lesser extent.
If mom must go, the only way to be sure her infant’s developing brain is getting what human biology demands for healthy growth is to provide a surrogate mother or nanny whose care is loving, consistent, and dependable for a long time.e Such care is expensive, for obvious reasons, and very difficult to find. Even with oodles of cash to throw at the problem, money cannot always—or even usually—buy the kind of unselfish care a mother is naturally inclined to give to her child.f
When “quality daycare” is presented as the panacea for all that ails daycare in general, the exact definition of what that means—or how it could realistically be provided for infants—is never explained. The reason is simple: It is just a dream, a nebulous idea that sounds good but makes absolutely no sense economically. For infants, quality is one thing: a happy, devoted mama. And if she is unavailable, the optimal option is someone who is willing and able to attend to the baby with the same level of devotion—and I dare say, optimal should be our goal.
With this standard in mind, we now turn to the reality for infants spending many hours per week in daycare. Obviously, daycare centers are businesses that are organized like any business, with profit—the bottom line—dictating how they will operate and how the children there will be “cared for.” They cannot provide anything approaching the care a mother would give her child, and so they don’t even pretend to. Rather than promoting the image of a caring place where dependable relationships are formed, they promote the image of a learning center where children can start gaining the skills they will need to be successful academically. Ironically, long hours in daycare create learning disabilities in millions of children. This reality will be discussed in greater detail in the next chapter.
Sadly, the idea that daycare is better than home care for preparing children for school—another example of our anti‑mother culture—has been so thoroughly promoted in our society that many mothers and families believe they are doing what is best for their young children by putting them in daycare, even during infancy. They struggle to come up with the money because they believe they are giving their babies the best start in life. Comments can be seen on social media from mothers who have been convinced their baby would be better off at daycare but they just can’t get themselves to separate and take them. If they only knew how important they are for their baby’s developing brain and all of the future problems they are avoiding by just being there loving and caring for their own child.
So the day comes when mom and baby arrive at the center. Mom hands her child to people the baby has likely never even seen before—and leaves. Depending on the age and temperament of the child, the distress this causes will be more or less obvious to onlookers, ranging from no visible distress, especially for the very young, to desperate cries that continue for hours or days. No matter how it looks from the outside, everything we know about healthy infant emotional development suggests that separation from mother produces some degree of stress.
But why is being with mother so important?
As already noted, babies come into the world expecting a relationship with the very person with whom they shared a body not long before. This is because the healthy growth of their brains and emotional systems requires—and is built upon—a close relationship with someone who is consistent and reliable. To help ensure this close relationship forms, babies are equipped by nature with behaviors that woo and delight their mothers: their little gurgles, coos, and smiles. But they have to be together for the plan to work.
If mom suddenly disappears, the situation is so completely unnatural from an evolutionary sense, the baby has no developmental programming for understanding it. To put it another way, people are not interchangeable for the infant. What the baby needs is not simply an available adult, but the particular person with whom it has already begun forming a heart‑to‑heart and brain‑to‑brain connection.
The complexity of the baby’s newly developing brain—and the extraordinary speed at which it is growing—requires close contact with the mother for emotional regulation and a sense of safety. Held within a secure relationship, the infant’s emotional right brain forms patterns of expected behavior and can gradually make sense of its own feelings and those of others. But that foundation takes years to develop and is a complex and sensitive process, requiring that one special person. And by nature’s design, that person is the mother.
The neurological processes underlying this early relationship—and what happens when it is repeatedly interrupted—will be explored in detail in the next chapter. For now, it is enough to understand that the infant’s developing emotional system is shaped through thousands of intimate, moment‑by‑moment interactions with the person who has become the center of the baby’s world.
Healthy infant development within the context of an attuned relationship with the mother is a beautiful thing to see.g As that emotional connection strengthens throughout the first year, anyone who cares to notice can see its effects: a baby who is confident, comfortable in his or her own skin, aware of his or her surroundings, bright‑eyed, and open to connecting with others. Mom is standing by, and there’s nothing to be afraid of. Such secure babies are a joy to behold.
By contrast, many infants and toddlers who spend long hours in daycare appear to have a faraway, disconnected look and may be reluctant or unable to engage. It’s like the lights are on but no one’s home. They do not draw you into their orbit with facial expressions that encourage emotional connection. This is, of course, an observation rather than a clinical measure, but the difference is clearly detectable when looking into the eyes of some “daycare” babies and attempting to communicate.
One possible explanation for this difference is that while some babies—especially those with sensitive and vulnerable emotional systems—are spending all of those hours away from mom in the daycare center, their immature brains are struggling to make sense of what is happening. It’s like they are in a kind of holding pattern emotionally—waiting to reconnect, waiting for their life source to reappear. Certainly, there are people around, but no one who can connect in the intimate way the baby requires.
Even the warmest daycare worker does not share the same emotional connection and therefore cannot comfort and engage the baby in precisely the same way because the attachment process happens between baby and mother. At this stage of development, only she will do. And this is true even if the time necessary for attuned interaction and connection were available. As already noted, commercial daycare is not the place where close relationships are built. Strong attachments that could offer comfort during mother’s absence are impossible to provide simply because of the child‑to‑caregiver ratio. Warm, empathetic relationships are also discouraged because they make separation harder when the baby must move on to another room upon reaching a certain age. All daycare relationships are temporary and tenuous—the exact opposite of what a rapidly developing emotional brain needs.
Under these conditions, healthy development during the long day in center care is hard to imagine. It is easy to imagine baby’s internal state becoming organized around stress and self‑protection. Time that could have been spent—should have been spent—forming healthy neural connections within a secure relationship is instead spent coping with separation and the fear it engenders. Research has found repeated activation of the stress‑response system contributes to neural patterns designed for vigilance and self protection. The emotional message is one of abandonment: life is frightening and relationships are undependable.
This is entirely different from those neural patterns that naturally develop when mom is there and that create an emotional template of security, confidence, and a sense of self worth. Natural parenting that allows mother to nurture her baby creates a sense of joy that comes from being securely loved. When that connection is repeatedly broken through prolonged separation, the emotional system of sensitive babies can easily be set adrift, cast away in a sea of confusion, leading to stress responses and defensive behaviors that may then form the neural foundation for future anxiety, depression, and a plethora of other mental health disturbances. The question of just how damaging repeated and prolonged separations are for healthy emotional development begs for further research.
Finally mom shows up, and baby’s emotional system can calm down and become regulated again. At last, she is there, and the feelings of fear and abandonment can subside. But how is mom feeling? This is important because baby’s emotional system is intricately attuned to its mother’s. Baby experiences mom’s feelings in a visceral way. Is she calm and happy to be reunited with her infant? Maybe. But she, too, has also been dealing with the effects of separation, and the pressures of life as a working mom weigh heavily upon her. Her body and hormones have primed her to nurture her infant, and yet she has been forced—even if she thinks it’s a choice—to separate. Her body is telling her to get back to her baby, just as baby cannot feel at ease until it is reunited with her. But circumstances do not allow it, and she is stuck in a no‑win situation which is likely to produce feelings of sadness, guilt, and inadequacy—and perhaps even contribute to postpartum depression. Rarely can a mother drop everything after work and just nestle in with her baby for the entire evening—reconnecting, nursing, resting, enjoying. Instead she must begin her second shift: cooking or purchasing dinner, spending time with her partner, picking up the mess, feeding and washing the baby, bathing herself and getting ready for the next day’s work. The demands of two full‑time jobs, and the inability to give either her full energy and attention, are likely to leave her feeling out of control and exhausted. In her book You Don’t Have to Carry It All, journalist and working‑mother advocate Paula Faris states, “80 to 90 percent of [working] moms are struggling with burnout and mom guilt.”9
Imagine this nightmare continuing indefinitely for both baby and mama. Each day, the pain of separation happens all over again for baby. A true sense of abandonment is experienced over and over because, remember, baby does not yet have the mental ability to imagine the future or understand that mom is coming back. Baby knows only that she is gone, and the developing brain and nervous system activate the stress response, preparing baby for disaster yet again. The daycare center—that place hailed as a wonderful environment for joyful learning—is more like a turn‑of‑the‑century orphanage when it comes to meeting the emotional needs of an infant. Recall from Chapter 4 that neglect in orphanages caused such severe emotional and developmental problems in infants that the tragedies could not be ignored. They became one of the main drivers of attachment research. When we see our neighborhood daycare center, we don’t think of it as a center of neglect—but it is. By the standard of what the developing human brain requires, infants in daycare centers experience neglect on a consistent, repetitive, and enduring basis. This has nothing to do with the intentions of daycare workers. Most care about children and want to do their best by them. This problem is systemic, built into the institution, regardless of who is running it.
It is true, though, that some are decidedly worse than others. In the finest centers, infants are held often, fed and changed on time, and provided diversions like swings and toys. The caregiver to child ratio is relatively low. In others, there are not enough workers to provide even for these basic needs, and an additional level of neglect happens. It’s interesting that when a mother has triplets everyone sighs and says, Oh my, how in the world is she going to be able to care for three infants at once? And yet the laws of most states allow a ratio of one caregiver to four or more infants. And she isn’t even related to them. She is expected to be highly motivated to provide the best of care while being paid poverty‑level wages and offered minimal, if any, benefits. Why don’t we ask, How in the world can this person adequately care for so many babies? Because ultimately this is a business and the needs of the customers providing a profit must take a backseat to the business owners’ need to make a profit. Such are the values of a materialistic culture like ours. And so, morale is low, turnover is high, and the big losers are the babies and their families who have been told ad nauseam this is a good and healthy way to raise children.
As weeks turn into months and months into years, baby continues to experience feelings of neglect and abandonment—all at a subconscious level. None of this will be consciously remembered when the child, or later the adult, is trying to figure out the cause of their mental struggles. And mom is suffering too. The stress of working full‑time while raising an infant will produce changes in her, and possibly her marriage as well. To receive the full biological rewards of caring for her infant, a mother must be able to spend her minutes, hours, and days with her baby. Through all the minutiae of daily care and breastfeeding, mom continues to be rewarded through that cocktail of hormones that acts almost like a drug, bonding her ever more deeply to her baby. As time goes on, she loves that little being more than life itself, and caring for her baby feels like the absolute best thing she could possibly do, despite the lack of sleep and all the other inconveniences that come with it. This is nature’s way of guaranteeing she sticks to her task—and even enjoys it.
But when she is separated from baby for many hours each day, those loving interactions—and the feel‑good chemicals that accompany them—decrease dramatically leaving her with the responsibility and the work but far less of the reward. Now all of those messages society has drilled into her head about what a pain babies are begin to play. Perhaps she remembers how hard it was in high school when she had to take care of a doll that woke her in the middle of the night, supposedly teaching her about the responsibilities of motherhood. She didn’t have the feel‑good hormones in her system then, either. Working all day and then coming home to another “job,” one that continues through the night, gets old fast, and may lead her to think, Maybe they were right, this isn’t much fun. She may look at her husband sleeping peacefully and begin to resent him. Or perhaps he has been waking to do his part at night, and he is starting to resent her. The fights start. Whose turn is it to get up, feed the baby and change the dirty diaper? Caring for baby begins to feel like janitor’s work. And hey, we’re both important workers out in the world. Why should I do it all the time? Baby absorbs the tension and, instead of feeling adored, may begin to feel at a subconscious level, that their very existence is a burden to their parents. More on this when we discuss child suicide.
As baby grows and moves from the infant room to the toddler room, the feelings of neglect and abandonment become more conscious.h The older baby—baby here referring to a child from birth to age three—becomes increasingly aware of the distress caused by mother’s absence and longs to be reunited with her as the hours at the center drag on.i The holding pattern continues in an environment bereft of the meaningful emotional connection baby needs and filled with mind‑numbing monotony. While the daycare rhetoric describes an ever‑changing, intellectually stimulating place, the truth is that a daycare center is a custodial institution, following routines designed to keep groups of children safe. At home with mom, the scene is always changing because that is the nature of life outside of an institution: people coming and going; different activities and games; perhaps a family pet or two running around; walks through the neighborhood; trips to the park; and, certainly, trips to the grocery store. In addition to all of that variety—wonderful food for a developing brain—the best part is mom is right there, supplying comfort when something is upsetting and sharing in the fun as new adventures unfold.
During a tour of a local daycare center, the caregivers explained that educational materials, such as books and posters, were organized around themes and changed frequently, consistent with the expectations of a “learning center.” The toddlers also had access to engaging toys. When I entered, a group of eight toddlers was situated around a large rectangular table, each with a cool‑looking toy in front of them. Yes, they each had a toy that might light up, make noises, or spin around, and a few tried halfheartedly to play with theirs, but most simply stared at them. Without an emotionally connected adult to share the experience, a toy like that isn’t much fun. When you imagine a small child playing with a colorful, spinning toy that makes sounds, you picture a family member on the floor with the child, activating the toy and saying something excitedly to capture the baby’s interest. But these kids had no one. They had toys placed in front of them at a table and were expected to find them interesting and play without anyone playing with them. Most looked numb, and one little girl, about two years old, quietly cried. I asked one of the caregivers why she was crying. “There’s just no pleasing her,” she said. “She’s always miserable.” And that was that. There was no one wrapping their arms around her and telling her everything would be all right. In fact, offering that kind of comfort is impossible, lest every child who is suffering from neglect begin crying for some individualized attention.
If every distressed child suffering from neglect began crying for some personal attention, the entire system would break down.
We are sold an image by the daycare industry of happy children playing with each other while their young minds are being stimulated and their future success assured. Just like billboards selling beer, daycare brochures show broad smiles on contented‑looking faces. But how many of us have actually spent enough time inside a daycare center to observe what life is really like for the children—even babies—spending the majority of their waking hours there?
When trying to decide the best way to raise her children in the late 1970’s, Deborah Fallows decided to do her own research and set out to systematically observe a wide variety of daycare centers over a three year period. Just as the women’s movement was taking off she was earning a bachelor’s degree from a prestigious liberal arts college in New England; exactly the kind of place to be steeped in feminist ideology. After completing a doctorate in linguistics she was ready to start her family. Like so many women coming of age at that time, especially college‑educated women, she felt she had to defend her desire to nurture her own children. In the introduction to her book, A Mother’s Work (1983) Fallows explains she decided to write the book because so many families were confused about the best way to balance work and family life. In her words: “My desires and feelings about the way I should raise children and be a mother suddenly seemed to place me at sharp, and unnecessary, odds with the women’s movement.”10
Fallows’ descriptions of typical days in daycare remain the most poignant in the published literature, even now, four decades later. They reveal a reality far removed from the happy one promoted by daycare advocates. The picture that emerges is one of boredom, frustration, coping, and just getting through by daycare workers who have been placed in an impossible situation. There is no way for them to give the babies in their care what they need for eight to ten hours a day because what the babies need is their mothers. For the children’s part, the picture is also one of boredom, frustration, and coping—with some who are extremely emotionally distressed and distraught, particularly those who are new to daycare and have not yet become resigned to their fate. Research by James Robertson, working with John Bowlby, identified three phases young children went through when separated from their mothers during long hospital stays with only brief, if any, parental visits allowed: protest, despair, and detachment. The protest phase is characterized by crying, tantrums, and actively searching for mom. When the protest fails to bring her back, children enter the despair phase, often becoming withdrawn and showing signs of hopelessness. While still longing for mom, their outward expressions of hope diminish, leading to a state of deep sadness and despair. In the final phase children begin to emotionally detach from mom. They appear apathetic and show a reduced response to her absence or return, which can be a coping mechanism to manage their emotional pain.j More on this in the coming chapter.
This excerpt from Fallows’ book A Mother’s Work describes a morning visit to a KinderCare facility. It features a two‑year‑old named Stephen experiencing Robertson’s protest phase:
I went out to the playground with the two‑year‑olds… One blond [little boy] had been crying for a long time, his shoulders shaking, his clenched fists pressed to his mouth… Stephen came over to stand vigil next to him. His hands were in fists next to his mouth, too, but he wasn’t crying. After about ten minutes, Stephen worked up the nerve to wander away from the teacher… He sat next to a child who had collected dirt in a paper cup. They seemed on the verge of playing together or side by side. Just then one of the teachers came over to the child who had collected the dirt, took the paper cup, and spilled the dirt out. The child wandered away and left Stephen by himself… The other little boy was still crying and had now wet his pants… Stephen came to sit next to me… and said, “My momma come soon.” [The toddlers were then taken inside for bathroom time.] “No playing,” said Toby, one of the teachers… There were thirteen two‑year‑olds, so the process of going one by one to the bathroom and washing hands afterward was slow and painstaking. In the background, a second drama was being played out. One little boy started in, “I want my mommy.” A second followed suit. A third boy sat by himself at one of the tables crying softly, “I want my mommy, I wanna go to Mommy’s house.” A fourth boy walked over to the teacher. He shouted, “Mommy!” “Yeah, Mommy’s coming,” said the teacher. “Daddy!” “Yeah, Daddy’s coming, too,” she said tiredly… [Afterwards the teacher began trying to read a story that was obviously over the children’s heads and was actually above her level for reading fluently. A few who were right in front of the book seemed slightly interested in the pictures but the rest were “looking elsewhere.”] Every few pages [the teacher] interrupted herself trying to keep the children in line. “No kicking. Keep your hands to yourself. Yes, Mother’s coming, okay? Yes, your mother’s coming also. No, no hitting. Be quiet.” Stephen began wailing incessantly for his mother.11
Fallows’ account continues with Stephen crying through lunch, bits of food coming out of his mouth; resisting naptime; and repeatedly asking when his mom would arrive—and Fallows realizing that his mother would not be coming mid‑day to pick him up, as the teachers had been telling him all morning. Stephen was made to lie down on his cot. She wrote that the morning had left her feeling so nauseated she decided to take a walk outside. As she circled the building she saw Stephen through a window screaming and crying and thrashing about on his cot.
Young children feeling abandoned in group care is a serious form of neglect. Long days rolling into months that become the first years of a baby’s life create the possibility of psychic wounds and defensive patterns—patterns that become permanently embedded in the child’s nervous system, shaping responses to social situations and wrecking what could have been a good life. Remember, this is the time when the baby’s brain is growing more than it ever will again.k Through a process called synaptogenesis, neural connections are forming at an astronomical 2,400,000 per minute. Such dynamic growth under conditions of neglect does not produce the kind of learning parents want. Instead of growing up happy and confident, we are systematically producing children who grow into sad and anxious adults—not the ideal picture painted by daycare proponents and certainly not what parents would willingly choose for their kids. But leaving children in daycare for the full workday has become so common that we are desensitized to what that experience is really like, desensitized to the pain being inflicted on the young and innocent as a regular part of childhood in the United States and throughout much of the modern world.
Psychologists and trauma specialists increasingly warn that neglect can be even more traumatic than physical abuse. With more mothers with children under three employed, we know this form of neglect is widespread.l Furthermore, we have no idea just how damaging it is for babies to suffer a sense of abandonment and neglect over and over again during those critical first years—at the very time their brains are undergoing the greatest growth and development of their entire life span. The wholesale abandonment of children in daycare centers is a relatively new phenomenon in our “civilized” society and the research needed to reveal the full extent of the damage is just not being done.
Our culture endorses child‑rearing practices that inflict psychic pain on its youngest and most vulnerable members as standard procedure. We are not responding to the ravages of war, as Britain was when the Hampstead Nurseries were created out of sheer necessity during World War II.m No, there’s no actual crisis that necessitates such cruel and inhumane treatment of babies and their mothers. Yet the average citizen has been propagandized and brainwashed to believe that, yes, we are in a crisis—an economic crisis that demands the unfortunate but necessary separation of mothers from their babies. The typical reaction from those I tell about the subject of this book is, But mothers have to work. They have no choice.
This is exactly what those who have created the reality surrounding modern motherhood want everyone—especially mothers themselves—to believe. So, with the best intentions, mothers leave their babies, but not without serious consequences for themselves as well as their children. When listening to mothering podcasts or reading books about balancing work and family life, the topic of mother guilt reigns supreme. Young women who have chosen to become mothers are made to believe they have no choice but to continue as they did before, as though nothing significant had even happened. Just a minor blip in the road. Mama, resume your pre‑baby life as soon as possible. There’s only one problem: this is impossible, because becoming a mother is the most profound change that can happen in a young woman’s life; her brain, her body, her emotions—her entire existence—will never be the same. She has grown and birthed another human being, and even if she doesn’t realize how important she is to the healthy development of her child, her nature knows. Her body and subconscious mind are operating on another system of values, telling her to stay with—or get back to—her baby, to nurture her baby, to make sure her baby is safe and healthy.
This difference between the modern cultural script and nature’s requirements puts the mother who decides to leave her baby for long hours in a daycare center between a rock and a hard place. Society is telling her it’s okay, but her biology is telling her it’s not. Guilt is the result. Why do people experience guilt? What is the purpose of guilt from an evolutionary perspective? As social animals, humans evolved within family groups and depended on remaining within the group for survival. Being banished and forced to live alone meant certain death, so people needed a built‑in way to recognize when their behavior had violated group expectations to avoid being expelled—and that is the feeling of guilt. Guilt is nature’s way of making us suffer if our actions have hurt someone important to us. It’s our warning system urging us to repair the damage—to make things right. Guilt is therefore a positive mechanism, allowing us to feel the effects our behavior is having on others, to empathize when we have hurt someone so we can fix the relationship. As long as a mother continues to leave her baby, her emotional system will produce painful feelings of guilt designed to motivate her to make the situation right for her child—to repair the damage that has been done by her departure. Separation that is dangerous to her baby is meant to be painful for her. It’s nature’s way of getting the two back together where they belong.
If she believes she has no choice, she will suffer. The pain can be unbearable. In an effort to ease the pain, her conscious mind will search for rationalizations—conveniently provided by our anti‑baby culture—to help her feel better. Ideas like Quality of time is what matters, not the quantity of time spent together. She will seek comfort from other moms who are also being squeezed by a no‑win cultural reality. They will support one another in standing firm and declaring their right to be important people, not just someone’s mother. They are creating a better material life for their children. They are doing important work for which their family can be proud. A happy, fulfilled mother out in the world of work makes for a better mother at home. She must be a dedicated warrior for equality, continuing to fight against the terrible imbalance of power that has existed between men and women. And on and on it goes, and yet the guilt continues…
All close relationships require time together to remain strong, just as romantic relationships need a certain level of participation from each partner. That is why most people will agree that long‑distance relationships are usually doomed. Oxytocin, known as the “love” hormone, is released through affectionate touch. The relationship between a mother and her baby also requires lots of time together—which naturally includes lots of touch—to remain close. If mom is away all day, not rewarded biologically for caring for her infant or toddler and also suffering painful guilt feelings, there is a strong likelihood that she will begin to separate not only physically, but psychologically from her child.no William and Wendy Dreskin witnessed this painful phenomenon time and again in their daycare center. Their story is relevant.
In 1973, the Dreskins opened a preschool. They were both teachers who loved providing a rich experience for little people just beginning their school years. In keeping with the developmental needs of children, their program operated mornings only, from nine to twelve, for children ages three to five. Parents were encouraged to become involved with the school, and participation in parent meetings was high. The families and the school functioned together for the good of the children. The children were thriving.
But society was changing, more mothers were going to work full‑time, and there was growing pressure to provide daycare for the entire day. The Dreskins believed they could still keep quality high and give the children what they needed, even with the longer hours. They were idealistic and believed in the power of quality daycare, just as many still do. “We did not have the slightest suspicion that there might be a serious problem with even the best daycare programs.”12 The pressure of full days apart began to take an undeniable toll on the children and the parents. The children who had thrived in the morning program “[became] different children when they were subjected to the stress of full‑time day care.”13 Parents, too, became too busy to remain involved with the school. They also seemed less interested—too busy and tired—to give their children their full attention when they finally made it back to the center to pick them up. More on this in a moment.
The terrible effects of too many hours in daycare became unbearable for the Dreskins to witness, and they made the difficult decision to close the center that had been the focus of their lives for five years. Explaining why, they wrote:
Full‑time day care, particularly group care, is not an adequate substitute for time spent with parents, and can be especially harmful for children under the age of three. For two years we watched day care children in our preschool/day care center respond to the stresses of eight to ten hours a day of separation from their parents with tears, anger, withdrawal, or profound sadness, and we found, to our dismay, that nothing in our own affection and caring for these children would ease this sense of loss and abandonment… The problem was not with our facility; the amount of toys and educational materials far exceeded the supplies of most centers. The problem was not our well‑trained, credentialed staff; all staff members were qualified people who really liked and cared about young children. After two years of doing day care, it was obvious that there was a problem inherent in day care itself, a problem that hung like a dark storm over good and bad day care centers alike… The children were too young to be spending so much time away from their parents. They were like young birds being forced out of the nest and abandoned by their parents before they could fly, their wings undeveloped, unready to carry them out into the world.14
The Daycare Nightmare is a trap that has been set up for parents—mothers especially—to unwittingly fall into. Most have no idea what life is really going to be like or how they are going to feel while acting out the unnatural cultural script for parenting that has become so common. There is really no way to know until they are living it, and by then it can be too late, as we will examine in the next chapter. Many parents—especially mothers who are usually the primary nurturers while their children are babies—blindly go along assuming that, of course, they will still love and enjoy being with and caring for their children, even if they don’t spend much time together. And some do. But that is not always how it goes. As previously mentioned, human affection and connection are strengthened by hormones released through loving interaction and time spent with that special person. If that loving connection is cut off, feelings can change.
The example of two lovers living separately can help make this clear. Perhaps they are married, but circumstances have forced them apart for long stretches of time. The separation can alter their brain chemistry, and one or both may find they no longer feel the same. Without the regular closeness that keeps those feel‑good, love chemicals flowing, they may no longer enjoy being together as they once did. The happiness and satisfaction they used to experience together just seemed to evaporate. When this happens, they may find themselves pretending they still feel the same. If they can’t find a way to be together more often, there’s a good chance they will end up separating for good.
When a mother is separated from her baby most of the time, the same phenomenon can occur. She is no longer spending enough time in the close, loving interactions that stimulate those wonderful hormonal rewards designed to keep her happy and content while mothering. She knows she should want to spend her evenings caring for her child and yet she doesn’t always feel that way. Now she must pretend. In some part of her mind she wishes she could just have the evenings to herself like she did before becoming a mother and this causes her to feel guilty. After a long, tiring day at work, the negative feelings she has begun to associate with caring for her child even affect the precious “quality time” that was supposed to keep this whole house of cards from falling.
The idea that a mother who is fulfilled out in the world of work makes a better mother when she’s back with her child is accepted as truth by many these days. It sounds good, and sometimes it may actually be true. It just doesn’t usually work out that way. The problem is that this scenario doesn’t take into account the phenomenon just described—how feelings can change as a result of separation. The Dreskins often heard this claim from the working mothers at their daycare center. The mothers said they were happier working and that “this made the quality of the time spent with their children better.”15 The following interaction at pickup time between a little boy named Carl and his mother suggests a different reality:
Carl’s mother arrives at 6:00 P.M. tired and frazzled. Carl tries to show her a picture he has painted. [Remember, he has been waiting all day for this moment of reconnection.] “Show me later. Get your lunch box. Come on.” She is already halfway out the door. Carl trails after her, crying at the rebuff and at the effort of trying to balance his painting, his lunch box, his fire engine, and the cup of fruit salad he made in a cooking project that afternoon. We can tell from his mother’s mood what sort of evening Carl will have. So much for the precious two hours he will get to spend with his mother between leaving day care and going to bed.16
Raising young children is a full‑time job in itself, especially if a mother has more than one—say, children only a year or two apart—or when the baby is very young.p Actually, caring for an infant is more than a full‑time job because infants require around‑the‑clock care. When another full‑time job is piled on, the demands placed on the mother become unreasonable and unbearable. Just as the new cultural script shows happy babies in daycare, moms who can “do it all” are expected to feel satisfied with all they are achieving with their superwoman status. They are told they have “come a long way” and should be happy. And yet how can they be when they are being asked to do the impossible?
In her book You Don’t Have to Carry It All, Emmy award‑winning journalist Paula Faris admitted, “As the mom of three kiddos, I’ve always worked. But I’ve always felt torn. And I’ve never in the history of my time as a mama ever felt like I was nailing it. Burnout? Check. The constant juggle and mental load? Check. Conflict between working and momming? Check.”17
Along these lines, mental health counselor Mary Beth Somich says, “Many mothers say they are expected to work like they are not mothers and mother like they don’t work.”18
This impossible situation leads mothers to do whatever they can to survive. They read books on how to run their homes as they would a business, with every task tucked into neat little scheduled boxes to try to eke out a few extra minutes each day.q Children get squeezed into those boxes whether they like it or not. Too bad, kids, mom—these are the harsh realities of modern life, so deal with it. Everyone is told their feelings are invalid. The child who complains about having to go to daycare is told, “You’re okay. It’s not that bad.” The mother who feels burned out, dissatisfied, and exhausted tells herself she has absolutely no choice. After all, she’s winning. She has it all. While every member of the family feels squeezed by this new definition of successful family life, they all feel they must just power through, regardless of the negative consequences that are surely being created by this stressful and unnatural way of raising children.
Erica Djossa is a psychotherapist who had three boys in three and a half years. She resumed her professional career as soon as her maternity leave following the birth of her third child ended. “Happily,” she says, she couldn’t wait to get back to work. After powering through under the ridiculous burden of having three children in rapid succession, putting them into daycare, and returning to a full‑time job, she suffered a breakdown, collapsing in her driveway with uncontrollable vomiting. At that point, she could no longer pretend that all was well. Something obviously had to give. Unfortunately, it was time with her children. She decided that, to restore her mental health, she had to reclaim her independence, to free herself from what she calls the “mother load,”r and to allocate five minutes in the evening to each of her sons before bedtime so they would have no doubt that they mattered to her.
While discussing her survival strategies with mental health counselor Mary Beth Somich on Djossa’s podcast, Momwell, Djossa explained that during the bedtime routine, the best thing to do is spend five minutes of quality time so your child knows without a doubt you are completely focused on him or her for that five minutes. They can count on those five minutes to connect with mom and share any triumphs or concerns from the day.19
Djossa has made maternal mental health the focus of her psychotherapy practice, and she is teaching other mothers to also prioritize their needs ahead of those of their dependent children in order to stay sane. In a conversation with Tami Simon of Sounds True, Djossa described living with ADHD and struggling with household organization, even finding seasonal tasks such as changing over the family’s clothing overwhelming.20 Her experience and her ADHD help explain the perspective she brings to motherhood: that many of the responsibilities traditionally assigned to wives and mothers can feel burdensome and unsustainable, and that cultural expectations must change to protect mothers’ mental health. More broadly, the question of how a mother’s own experience of being nurtured in infancy may influence her capacity to nurture her children will be explored further in the following chapter.
In a completely transparent and heartfelt podcast episode, Dr. Tarryn MacCarthy tells the story of how her life had become a “nightmare” under the pressure of running a dental practice while being responsible for her two young children, both still in diapers. She begins the podcast by explaining that, while out of her mind with stress, she ran over the beloved family dog, whose injuries were so severe it had to be put to sleep. In her words:
On that day I was flying home after a full day at work, then taking the kids to fly to the grocery store to get dinner and milk… and flying home just to try to start the bedtime routine. Just to get them into bed… to fall apart on the couch with a martini in hand. That’s when I hit our dog. I was miserable… I was so unhappy. Nothing felt good enough, I didn’t feel good enough… The fact that I only hit a dog still blows my mind because I was… in a state of absolute fight or flight… And never considering how my suffering was causing suffering around me. I was raising human beings, these impressionable, beautiful little kids that I was just squeezing into my day. I was just hoping for getting them into bed at night, hoping for an easy bedtime. God forbid we had a moment of norovirus.s I’ll never forget when I stayed up all night cleaning up… and knowing the next morning I’d see patients at 8 AM. Knowing I’d have to pump before I got out of the house and just every moment resenting the next vomiting episode of my kids. There’s no way I was showing up as my best self for them… I kept telling myself I can do this and I was completely unaware that my suffering was causing others to suffer too… I told myself just a little bit longer, you’ll find happiness and peace and calm and ease.21
Dr. MacCarthy marvels that her Daycare Nightmare resulted only in the death of the family dog. Other families, similarly distracted by the inhumane stress they are being pushed to live under, have not been so lucky. Every now and then we hear in the news that a parent—sometimes mother, sometimes father—simply forgot to drop their child at daycare before going to work, only realizing their mistake upon returning at pickup time and being told the child was never dropped off. The child is then found dead in the car from exposure to extreme heat. While reporting on a string of similar tragedies in Florida, an evening news anchor suggested that parents place their laptops next to the car seat to help them remember their child—implying that the need for their computer may be occupying more space in parents’ minds than the needs of their dependent children.
All of this points to a system of distraction and neglect that forms the basis of a true nightmare for babies and their families—and, ultimately, for all of us who make up the human community. Babies come into the world expecting to be held, nursed, and nurtured, and to form a relationship with their mothers first and most importantly, and then with other family members. Mothers expect, at least subconsciously, to be allowed—through cultural norms created to ensure the healthy growth of the next generation—to nurture their own children. This is the evolutionary plan that is older than time.
When babies’ formative years are spent separated from those who love them and are meant to be with them, they suffer in myriad ways. For many, a deep sense of unworthiness sets in. They begin to believe subconsciously that if they are so uninteresting or unimportant they cannot even get their own mother to want to spend time with them, there must be something wrong with them. Children who experience abandonment and neglect see themselves as broken and unworthy without even knowing why. They blame themselves subconsciously when, in truth, they are just the innocent victims of a system dominated by those with the power to put their own selfish needs above those of children who have no political voice—children who are completely dependent on adults to understand how vulnerable they are and to provide what they need to flourish. Once they get old enough to feel the pain of separation consciously, they start asking to please be allowed to stay home with their family, only to be told how much they are loved and that they are being left for their own good. Children do not buy that story because, at a heart level, they know in most cases it is not true, even if their mother has been convinced it is. In fact, in a sane society it would never happen. From the deepest part of their being they are forced to conclude that something must be wrong with them.
Ingrained patterns of anxiety, depression, and unworthiness are the main lessons learned from spending the first years of life in the “learning center.” People are different. Some may get through unscathed, but the sheer number of children—millions—suffering from mental dysfunction tells us that many do not. We will now turn to an in‑depth exploration of the neurobiology of early brain development and the conditions that foster secure attachment and a strong foundation for mental health. From there, we will consider the myriad forms our Daycare Nightmare can take when children are denied these essential conditions.
Footnotes & Endnotes
Footnotes
a. There is a plethora of books written by women who stepped away from professional careers to become their infant’s primary caregivers—and lived to tell the tale. They are written as though caring for one’s own baby were the domestic equivalent of surviving Navy SEAL training. ↩︎
b. The exact number of infants in daycare centers is difficult to determine. National surveys define and measure child‑care arrangements differently, and published statistics frequently group children from birth through age five together rather than reporting infants separately. ↩︎
c. It may be helpful to refer back to Chapter 3 on the neurobiology of infant bonding to be reminded of the critical importance of mother’s loving presence to her baby’s healthy development. ↩︎
d. Ferber recommends beginning no earlier than four months, although the pressure to return to work full‑time may lead some mothers to attempt sleep training earlier. ↩︎
e. Recall Bowlby’s nanny Minnie left his life when he was four years old. She had been the only mother figure he had known and losing her at such a young age was devastating; an event that shaped his life’s work and something he said he never completely got over. ↩︎
f. Renowned anthropologist and primatologist Sarah Blaffer Hrdy has vociferously pushed for government funding for “quality daycare” for working mothers. Yet for her third child, Niko, she hired a sensitive, loving, live‑in nanny that was still living with the family when her son was twelve. See Sarah Blaffer Hrdy, Mother Nature: A History of Mothers, Infants, and Natural Selection (New York: Pantheon Books, 1999), 113. ↩︎
g. A clip on the NurtureDream.org Facebook page shows a mother pretending to sneeze while her infant son studies her face intently before responding with contagious laughter. It’s a beautiful example of the joy shared within an attuned mother‑infant relationship. One will never witness this type of joy being expressed by an infant in any daycare center. ↩︎
h. In Staying Home: From Full‑Time Professional to Full‑Time Parent, one of the mothers interviewed explained her decision to return home to her daughter: “I really couldn’t deal with the guilt anymore. I didn’t want to spend any more time away from my daughter. When I worked full‑time, every night she’d ask, ‘Mom, is tomorrow a workday?’ If I said yes, she’d start crying. If I said no, she’d start jumping up and down on the bed with joy.” ↩︎
i. As we will see in the next chapter, cortisol research suggests that the daycare day may become more stressful, not less, as babies move into toddlerhood. ↩︎
j. Vividly illustrated in Robertson’s 1952 film, “A Two‑Year‑Old Goes to Hospital.” ↩︎
k. Scientists call this period the human growth spurt. ↩︎
l. Although the two are related—neglect is correlated with physical abuse. ↩︎
m. Recall Anna Freud’s observation that babies separated from their mothers in the Hampstead War Nurseries steadily deteriorated psychologically. They would rather endure a miserable bomb shelter with their mothers, she concluded, than live in the relative luxury of the nurseries without them. ↩︎
n. Recall the NICHD finding discussed in Chapter 6: across the first three years, the more hours children spent in nonmaternal care, the less sensitive their mothers were during observed mother‑child interactions and the less positively engaged the children were. The association was modest, but it points in precisely the direction described here. ↩︎
o. A related phenomenon can occur when a new mother was not adequately nurtured as a baby and is deprived of the full biological rewards of caring for her own baby. This will be discussed in the next chapter. ↩︎
p. Remember, the term baby is referring to children three and under. ↩︎
q. Author Julie Morgenstern’s book Time to Parent: Organizing Your Life to Bring Out the Best in Your Child and You (New York: Henry Holt, 2018) is one example. ↩︎
r. Djossa is the author of Releasing the Mother Load: How to Carry Less and Enjoy Motherhood More (New York: Harper Horizon, 2023). ↩︎
s. The Daycare Nightmare presented in this book does not even include the amount of disease babies are exposed to by being with groups of children where so many diapers are being changed. The risk of infection is high, with some diseases causing permanent disability or even death. ↩︎
Endnotes
1. Greer Kirshenbaum, The Nurture Revolution: Grow Your Baby’s Brain and Transform Their Mental Health through the Art of Nurtured Parenting (New York: Balance, 2023), 13. ↩︎
2. Richard Ferber, Solve Your Child’s Sleep Problems, new rev. and expanded ed. (New York: Simon & Schuster, 2006), 74–81. ↩︎
3. James J. McKenna, Safe Infant Sleep: Expert Answers to Your Cosleeping Questions (Washington, DC: Platypus Media, 2020), 142. ↩︎
4. McKenna, Safe Infant Sleep. ↩︎
5. Ibid. ↩︎
6. Ibid., 61. ↩︎
7. Ibid., 261. ↩︎
8. Ibid., 36–37. ↩︎
9. Paula Faris, You Don’t Have to Carry It All: Ditch the Lies, Reclaim Your Worth, and Finally Experience True Rest (Minneapolis: Bethany House, 2023), 216. ↩︎
10. Deborah Fallows, A Mother’s Work (Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 1985), 1. ↩︎
11. Ibid., 97–100. ↩︎
12. William Dreskin and Wendy Dreskin, The Day Care Decision: What’s Best for You and Your Child (New York: M. Evans and Company, 1983), 11. ↩︎
13. Ibid. ↩︎
14. Ibid., 18, 59. ↩︎
15. Ibid., 115. ↩︎
16. Ibid. ↩︎
17. Faris, You Don’t Have to Carry It All, xii. ↩︎
18. Erica Djossa, host, “161: Navigating Working Mom Struggles with Mary Beth Somich, Mental Health Counselor,” Momwell, February 22, 2023, podcast audio, 40:51, https://www.momwell.com/blog/navigating-working-mom-struggles. ↩︎
19. Djossa, “161: Navigating Working Mom Struggles,” 40:51. ↩︎
20. Erica Djossa, interview with Tami Simon, “Erica Djossa: Releasing the Mother Load,” Sounds True: Insights at the Edge, May 14, 2024, podcast audio, https://www.soundstrue.com/a/resources/podcast/erica-djossa-releasing-the-mother-load/. ↩︎
21. Tarryn MacCarthy, “#287—Who Else Is Suffering Because You Are Suffering?,” The Business of Happiness, November 29, 2023, podcast audio, 4:52–10:26, https://buzzsprout.com/1438690/episodes/because-you-are-suffering. ↩︎